AdTech Processes, MarTech Processes, Web Analytics

Game Theory Attribution: The Model You’ve Probably Never Heard Of

As an online marketer, how do you attribute conversions and assign credit to the different channels in your conversion paths?

Do you use the obsolete last-click attribution model? Or the equally flawed first-click attribution model?

Attribution is hard enough without using the over-simplistic attribution models that currently exist.

But imagine if instead of using an attribution model that unfairly gives credit to different channels in a customer’s journey you could use one that assigns credit based on actual influence?

Enter game theory attribution.

What Is Game Theory?

Game theory is “the study of mathematical models of conflict and cooperation between intelligent rational decision-makers.”

– Myerson, Roger B. (1991). Game Theory: Analysis of Conflict, Harvard University Press

Game theory is used in a number of different fields, including economics, psychology, political science, poker, biology, and computer science.

Game theory can be used in either competitive or cooperative situations.

In cooperative situations, something known as the Shapley value (named after game theorist and Nobel prize winner Lloyd Shapley) is used to fairly distribute credit or value to each individual player/participant.

The team at Abakus have created a video that explains the Shapley value and how it can be applied to a card game where players are working together.

Here’s a quick recap of how game theory and the Shapley value was applied to the card game:

You first start by identifying each player’s contribution when they play individually, when 2 play together, and when all 3 play together.

Game theory using the Shapley value to determine each player's marginal value

Then, you need to consider all possible orders and calculate their marginal value – e.g. what value does each player add when player A enters the game first, followed by player B, and then player C.

Below are the 6 possible orders and the marginal value each player adds in the different combinations:

Game theory attribution marginal value

Now that we have calculated each player’s marginal value across all 6 possible order combinations, we now need to add them up and work out the Shapley value (i.e. the average) for each player.

FREE GUIDE: Understand The Key Elements Of A Successful Ad Tech/MarTech Project

From identifying which features will deliver the most value to discovering how to release your Ad Tech/MarTech platform sooner...

Download FREE Guide

Here’s how it looks:

Game theory attribution value of player A
When you add up Player A's marginal value from the 6 possible orders and divide it by 6, you get a Shapley value of 7.7
Game theory attribution value of player B
When you add up Player B's marginal value from the 6 possible orders and divide it by 6, you get a Shapley value of 3.2
Game theory attribution value of player C
When you add up Player C's marginal value from the 6 possible orders and divide it by 6, you get a Shapley value of 8.1

Now that we have worked out the Shapley value for each player, we can clearly see the true contribution each player made to the game and assign credit fairly. In this example, player C contributed the most, followed by A, then by B.

How Can Game Theory Be Applied To Attribution?

The main problem with the current, predefined attribution models is that they don’t take into account each touchpoint’s influence in the overall customer journey.

For example, with the first-click attribution model, the first interaction a customer has in their customer journey is given all the credit for the eventual conversion, when in fact it may have been the second to last and last interaction that actually influenced the customer to convert (e.g. purchase a product from an ecommerce store).

First-click attribution model
The first-click attribution model only assigns credit to the first interaction, even if the other 2 touchpoints were more influential on the customer’s decision to convert.

And while custom attribution models, like those found in Google Analytics, allow you to create custom rules to change how credit for each touchpoint is awarded (e.g. by applying user engagement metrics), they don’t take into account the individual and combined influence of all the touchpoints in a conversion path.

As game theory attribution assigns (with the help of algorithms and the Shapley value) each touchpoint fair credit for a conversion based on their true contribution, it paints a clearer and more accurate picture of the custom journey and identifies which touchpoints perform the best and which ones don’t.

So now let’s take a look at how the same channels could fare when we apply game theory attribution and the Shapley value to them:

Game theory attribution shapley value
Game theory attribution uses algorithms and the Shapley value to identify the impact of each touchpoint and then fairly distribute credit to each touchpoint in a conversion path.

As you can see, all of the different touchpoints have been given different percentages of credit for the conversion.

The obvious main advantage of game theory attribution is that it assigns more accurate and fairer credit to each touchpoint than traditional, predefined attribution models – therefore allowing you to distribute marketing funds in a more, shall I say, data-driven way.

However, game theory attribution, just like all attribution models, does have its flaws. For instance, it calculates value based on previous observations – i.e. the Shapley value states that the value of an AdWords ad will be the same when followed by a direct visit and a paid search ad – but this order won’t influence every consumer in the same way every time.

So is game theory the perfect solution to the cross-channel attribution problem? No, but it’s certainly a lot better than the other ones out there like last-click and first-click.

The truth is that attribution in advertising and marketing will always be something marketers improve, rather than perfect, and game theory attribution is a big improvement.

Search

Get our whitepaper!

Understand The Key Elements Of A Successful AdTech/MarTech Project

From identifying which features will deliver the most value to discovering how to release your Ad Tech/MarTech platform sooner...

Download Now

Share this article

Sign up for our newsletter

If you are interested in receiving fresh content about analytics and advertising technologies, sign up for our newsletter!